Choosing an estate agent deserves more care than most sellers give it, because your agent controls the price you achieve, the speed of your sale, and how stressful it feels. The difference between a good agent and a poor one is not charm — it is evidence: recent sales of homes like yours, a realistic valuation, a marketing plan beyond a portal listing, and a contract you understand before signing. This guide is mainly for sellers, but buyers benefit too. Interview properly, compare like with like, and never sign on the strength of a valuation alone.
Shortlist and Interview
Start with at least three agents, and include a mix: the big local name, a strong independent, and an online or hybrid agent if you want to compare costs. For each one, ask the same questions so you can compare answers honestly. How many homes like yours have they sold locally in the last six months, at what percentage of asking price, and how long did they take to sell? What is their fall-through rate? A good agent answers with numbers and examples; a weak one answers with adjectives. Ask to see a recent listing of theirs — photographs, description, floorplan — because that is what your home will look like. Check their reviews, but read the bad ones properly: a pattern of complaints about communication matters more than one angry review. Notice how they treat you in the meeting: pushy, vague, or late now means the same service later.
Fees and What They Include
Fees are usually quoted as a percentage of the sale price plus VAT, and the headline rate is only half the story. A traditional high-street agent typically charges between 1 and 2 percent plus VAT, while online agents charge a fixed upfront fee that you pay whether or not the home sells. The question is what the fee buys: professional photography, a floorplan, an Energy Performance Certificate if needed, portal listings, accompanied viewings, and negotiation. Some agents charge extra for premium portal listings, brochures, or accompanied viewings — ask for the full list in writing. Also ask whether the fee is payable on exchange or completion, and whether you pay if you withdraw or switch agents. A cheap fee that buys a phone photograph and an unaccompanied viewing is not a bargain; it is a slower sale at a lower price. Compare total cost at your expected sale price, not just the percentage — and remember VAT adds a fifth on top.
Valuations: The Overvaluing Trap

The most expensive mistake in choosing an agent is picking the one who quotes the highest price. Some agents deliberately overvalue to win your instruction, knowing they can talk you down later after weeks of no viewings — by which time your home looks stale and buyers wonder what is wrong with it. The honest valuation is backed by evidence: recent sold prices for comparable homes nearby, adjusted for size, condition, and position. Ask each agent to show you those comparables and explain their figure. If one valuation is far above the others, ask why — a genuine reason (refurbishment, larger garden, unique feature) is fine, but “the market is moving” is not evidence. Price for the market you are in, not the market you wish you were in. A home priced correctly from day one attracts competing buyers and often achieves more than a home priced high and reduced in stages. Buyers should read valuations sceptically too: an overpriced home that has sat for months may accept a serious offer, especially if you arrive armed with good questions to ask at a viewing and a clear sense of comparable sold prices.
Contracts, Tie-Ins and Red Flags
Read the agency agreement before you sign, and understand three things: the tie-in period, the fee trigger, and the withdrawal terms. A sole agency agreement typically ties you to one agent for 8 to 16 weeks, during which you owe the fee even if you find your own buyer. A sole selling rights agreement goes further: you owe the fee even if you sell privately. Shorter tie-ins are better, and a notice period you can actually use matters more than a friendly promise. Check whether the fee is due if the sale falls through after exchange, and whether a buyer introduced by the first agent still triggers a fee if they buy later. Walk away from: pressure to sign on the spot, refusal to put fees and tie-ins in writing, valuations with no comparables, upfront payment demands from a traditional agent, and any suggestion to misdescribe the property. Once you have an agent you trust, the next professional to choose is your solicitor — our guide on how to choose a conveyancer applies the same evidence-first approach.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should I use an online agent to save money?
It depends. Online agents suit confident sellers with straightforward homes who are happy to conduct viewings themselves. If your home is unusual, high-value, or in a slow market, a local agent’s pricing knowledge and accompanied viewings usually earn their fee.
Can I negotiate an agent’s fee?
Yes, and most sellers do. Ask for a lower rate, a tiered fee (higher above a target price, lower below it), or a shorter tie-in. Get whatever is agreed written into the contract before you sign.
What if my home does not sell?
First, check the evidence: viewing numbers, feedback, and comparable sales. Usually the answer is price, presentation, or marketing — in that order. If your agent cannot show you what they have done and what they will change, it is time to consider switching once the tie-in allows.
Do I need different agents for buying and selling?
No — the selling agent works for the seller, not for you as a buyer. As a buyer, your own advisers are your solicitor or conveyancer and your surveyor. Judge the seller’s agent on responsiveness and honesty, but remember whose interests they serve.



